Divorce and Remarriage: The Sin Baptist Preachers Nod & Wink At

Yes, entry into a remarriage may be entered into based upon sinful pretexts, but if the involved parties have repented then the relationship is no different than your or my marriage.
And if they haven’t repented, but yet are legally married, then what’s their status with your church?
Should we presume that the church has authority to dig into your/my marriage to investigate whether we are indeed meeting all the expectations of the covenant at all times?
Yes, by being a member.
 
After all this discussion, I'm just wondering how David, "a man after God's own heart" was ever justified.
 
Just that sin only or any sin? What about a man who cheats on his wife once a year for the remainder of his lifetime? Or is that a different classification of sin?
Only God can read someone's heart as to whether they have repented or not. Many cheat and no one ever finds out. Many look at porn with no one ever finding out. There comes a point where you need to check your own heart and quit trying to find out if everyone else has a clean heart.
 
What does this even mean? Why do you presume they are living in sin?
Maybe because he or she is divorced and remarried. How does the authorities in the church know they’ve repented? If they’re members and have not repented, that’s not good for the body of Christ.
 
I’m talking about homosexuals who claim to be Christians defending their sinful lifestyles. Many divorced and remarried situations are like unscrambling Humpty Dumpty sitting on a wall with all the king’s horses and all the king’s men not being able to put Humpty Dumpty back together again after his fall. That is the plight of many in a fallen world. All the juicy gossip and dirt digging is none of your business or my business. The church is made up of sinful, fallen people who have by their own profession repented of past mistakes and are attempting to put their lives back together by following Christ to the best of their abilities. It isn’t for Pharisees to point their fingers and condemn those for whom God has forgiven.
But it is the pastors business, is it not? Don’t we want to keep the church pure. Maybe, the elders should have a sit down and find out if they’ve repented. And let them know that they shouldn’t be married unless they’ve repented than they are all good. Right? If not then the church body has sin in the camp.
 
And if they haven’t repented, but yet are legally married, then what’s their status with your church?

In need of counseling and/or discipline.
Yes, by being a member.
Seriously? You think that the elders should personally snoop into the marriage life of its members if there’s no evidence of them sinning?
 
Maybe because he or she is divorced and remarried. How does the authorities in the church know they’ve repented?

By sitting down with them when they ask to join the church, assuming there’s knowledge of the remarriage.
 
Only God can read someone's heart as to whether they have repented or not. Many cheat and no one ever finds out. Many look at porn with no one ever finding out. There comes a point where you need to check your own heart and quit trying to find out if everyone else has a clean heart.
The irony of you calling me a Pharisee. You classify sins on different scales based on your opinion. In a nutshell, a gay couple are worse sinners than a heterosexual couple because they are engaged in a sin that you find more offensive. Throw stones a lot??
 
In need of counseling and/or discipline.

Seriously? You think that the elders should personally snoop into the marriage life of its members if there’s no evidence of them sinning?
Yes, if they are joining the church for membership.
 
The irony of you calling me a Pharisee. You classify sins on different scales based on your opinion. In a nutshell, a gay couple are worse sinners than a heterosexual couple because they are engaged in a sin that you find more offensive. Throw stones a lot??
If there is a gay couple going to your church and the pastor doesn’t warn them of the eternal consequences unless they repent, their blood will be on his hands. Homosexuality has been normalized in many denominations and you are upset with preachers calling them out. Any straight couple involved in adultery or fornication is just as guilty if they believe they can live that way and be right with God. The lack of the preaching on repentance is leading men and women to hell because they believe they are justified by a belief that doesn’t reach the heart or change their lives. If you want a good study on repentance check out this book by Thomas Watson. It is the clearest explanation with illustrations I have ever personally read on the subject. It almost makes me want to become a Presbyterian.

 
Last edited:
Yes, if they are joining the church for membership.
I had asked “Should we presume that the church has authority to dig into your/my marriage to investigate whether we are indeed meeting all the expectations of the covenant at all times?” and that was in regards to currently active members, not prospective ones. Maybe we’re misunderstanding each other. Do you think that the church should snoop into the married lives of current members to see if they are sinning?
 
By sitting down with them when they ask to join the church, assuming there’s knowledge of the remarriage.
I’m curious. If you know they’re divorced and remarried what questions are the questions?
 
I’m curious. If you know they’re divorced and remarried what questions are the questions?
I’ve never had to be in that situation as an assistant pastor, but it would involve questions about the nature of marriage as a permanent covenant/bond, and if they would acknowledge their sinful part in the dissolution of their former marriage (or the possibility that they had legitimate “exceptions” clause reasons for their decision to remarry), and if they had repented of those former sinful thoughts and actions.
 
Back
Top