Missionaries Buying Property

  • Thread starter Thread starter mamamia
  • Start date Start date
M

mamamia

Guest
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.
 
I'm not a missionary............But there is nothing wrong with planning ahead for your family and future. I'm not 20 years old anymore but if I were I would be working 2 jobs and saving for the future. It's really planning ahead which is not wrong.
 
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You know.... stuff like this happens all the time. All the time. Missionaries usually run in circles of missionaries. They learn from each other and form friendships and partnership that foster this type of situation.

I can give you their response....... and in some ways... its a good response....

They will tell you they don't have a livelihood in which to get a retirement package or build experience to work their way "up the social ladder" so as to give future stability to their families.

On its face, they are right to some degree. However, its my opinion that they shouldn't "forgo" working to be a missionary. They should work just like anyone else. Learn a trade. Get experience. Get a job on their mission field. Be like the people they are working to help.

Its become rather common over the last 10 years for "missionaries" to get support to go to some area of the US they want to retire and live off their monthly support. Sometimes, there are more people looking to be missionaries in the US than any other countries.

I can't help but see some hypocrisy with such things.... I mean.... You really can't get a job in Montana and build a church at the same time!!!!!! What a joke.

 
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You bring up an interesting topic of caring for the missionary beyond the field.

We give our pastor a salary to pastor our Church. He can do most anything he wants with his money - the Church doesn't nickle and dime him.

Would it not be the same for a missionary?
 
christundivided said:
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You know.... stuff like this happens all the time. All the time. Missionaries usually run in circles of missionaries. They learn from each other and form friendships and partnership that foster this type of situation.

I can give you their response....... and in some ways... its a good response....

They will tell you they don't have a livelihood in which to get a retirement package or build experience to work their way "up the social ladder" so as to give future stability to their families.

On its face, they are right to some degree. However, its my opinion that they shouldn't "forgo" working to be a missionary. They should work just like anyone else. Learn a trade. Get experience. Get a job on their mission field. Be like the people they are working to help.

Its become rather common over the last 10 years for "missionaries" to get support to go to some area of the US they want to retire and live off their monthly support. Sometimes, there are more people looking to be missionaries in the US than any other countries.

I can't help but see some hypocrisy with such things.... I mean.... You really can't get a job in Montana and build a church at the same time!!!!!! What a joke.

Agreed on the US missionary thoughts. I have heard, though, that many foreign countries prohibit those on a religious visa from having any other form of employment in said country.
 
christundivided said:
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You know.... stuff like this happens all the time. All the time. Missionaries usually run in circles of missionaries. They learn from each other and form friendships and partnership that foster this type of situation.

I can give you their response....... and in some ways... its a good response....

They will tell you they don't have a livelihood in which to get a retirement package or build experience to work their way "up the social ladder" so as to give future stability to their families.

On its face, they are right to some degree. However, its my opinion that they shouldn't "forgo" working to be a missionary. They should work just like anyone else. Learn a trade. Get experience. Get a job on their mission field. Be like the people they are working to help.

Its become rather common over the last 10 years for "missionaries" to get support to go to some area of the US they want to retire and live off their monthly support. Sometimes, there are more people looking to be missionaries in the US than any other countries.

I can't help but see some hypocrisy with such things.... I mean.... You really can't get a job in Montana and build a church at the same time!!!!!! What a joke.

Elders who do their work well should be respected and paid well, especially those who work hard at both preaching and teaching. 1 Timothy 5:1

We are all missionaries in a way. Specially our pastors.
 
PR6771 said:
christundivided said:
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You know.... stuff like this happens all the time. All the time. Missionaries usually run in circles of missionaries. They learn from each other and form friendships and partnership that foster this type of situation.

I can give you their response....... and in some ways... its a good response....

They will tell you they don't have a livelihood in which to get a retirement package or build experience to work their way "up the social ladder" so as to give future stability to their families.

On its face, they are right to some degree. However, its my opinion that they shouldn't "forgo" working to be a missionary. They should work just like anyone else. Learn a trade. Get experience. Get a job on their mission field. Be like the people they are working to help.

Its become rather common over the last 10 years for "missionaries" to get support to go to some area of the US they want to retire and live off their monthly support. Sometimes, there are more people looking to be missionaries in the US than any other countries.

I can't help but see some hypocrisy with such things.... I mean.... You really can't get a job in Montana and build a church at the same time!!!!!! What a joke.

Agreed on the US missionary thoughts. I have heard, though, that many foreign countries prohibit those on a religious visa from having any other form of employment in said country.

You're right about the visas. There are times when this can't be done.
 
mamamia said:
Sherryh said:
I'm not a missionary............But there is nothing wrong with planning ahead for your family and future. I'm not 20 years old anymore but if I were I would be working 2 jobs and saving for the future. It's really planning ahead which is not wrong.

I have nothing against planning for the future.  But, most missionaries don't work a job outside of their ministry.  I know some missionaries truly struggling to stay on the field, while others are receiving above and beyond what they need allowing them to live in luxury while on the field.  I'm just not sure that's right.

The ones truly struggling ... I often wonder if this is God's way of saying, "time up" .... we never know the total story of a persons life, walk with God, goals .... for all we know, the struggling ones are ignoring a sin God won't let them ignore.
 
.tim said:
christundivided said:
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You know.... stuff like this happens all the time. All the time. Missionaries usually run in circles of missionaries. They learn from each other and form friendships and partnership that foster this type of situation.

I can give you their response....... and in some ways... its a good response....

They will tell you they don't have a livelihood in which to get a retirement package or build experience to work their way "up the social ladder" so as to give future stability to their families.

On its face, they are right to some degree. However, its my opinion that they shouldn't "forgo" working to be a missionary. They should work just like anyone else. Learn a trade. Get experience. Get a job on their mission field. Be like the people they are working to help.

Its become rather common over the last 10 years for "missionaries" to get support to go to some area of the US they want to retire and live off their monthly support. Sometimes, there are more people looking to be missionaries in the US than any other countries.

I can't help but see some hypocrisy with such things.... I mean.... You really can't get a job in Montana and build a church at the same time!!!!!! What a joke.

Elders who do their work well should be respected and paid well, especially those who work hard at both preaching and teaching. 1 Timothy 5:1

We are all missionaries in a way. Specially our pastors.

IF we are all missionaries.... Then I'm going to demand almost 30 years of back pay..... :)

As far as 1 Timothy 5:17 is concerned..... You should really study that little word "honor" your translation calls "paid well". Its it the exact same word used in John 4:44.

Joh 4:44  For Jesus himself testified, that a prophet hath no honour in his own country.

You translation must have "For Jesus himself testified, that a prophet hath no "pay" in his own country
 
christundivided said:
.tim said:
christundivided said:
mamamia said:
I don't believe that missionaries should live in poverty, but what's the Biblical way for missionaries to handle their money...er...God's money?  A family member of mine who is an IFB missionary, gets enough financial support to have a huge nest egg.  He wants to use this money to purchase investment property in the states so they have something to fall back on if/when they come of the field.  I'm struggling with whether or not this is right.  Don't churches give this money with the intention of it being used for ministry purposes, not retirement?  Would love to hear some thoughts on this.

You know.... stuff like this happens all the time. All the time. Missionaries usually run in circles of missionaries. They learn from each other and form friendships and partnership that foster this type of situation.

I can give you their response....... and in some ways... its a good response....

They will tell you they don't have a livelihood in which to get a retirement package or build experience to work their way "up the social ladder" so as to give future stability to their families.

On its face, they are right to some degree. However, its my opinion that they shouldn't "forgo" working to be a missionary. They should work just like anyone else. Learn a trade. Get experience. Get a job on their mission field. Be like the people they are working to help.

Its become rather common over the last 10 years for "missionaries" to get support to go to some area of the US they want to retire and live off their monthly support. Sometimes, there are more people looking to be missionaries in the US than any other countries.

I can't help but see some hypocrisy with such things.... I mean.... You really can't get a job in Montana and build a church at the same time!!!!!! What a joke.

Elders who do their work well should be respected and paid well, especially those who work hard at both preaching and teaching. 1 Timothy 5:1

We are all missionaries in a way. Specially our pastors.

IF we are all missionaries.... Then I'm going to demand almost 30 years of back pay..... :)

As far as 1 Timothy 5:17 is concerned..... You should really study that little word "honor" your translation calls "paid well". Its it the exact same word used in John 4:44.

Joh 4:44  For Jesus himself testified, that a prophet hath no honour in his own country.

You translation must have "For Jesus himself testified, that a prophet hath no "pay" in his own country

We can just read and come to our own conclusions I suppose ...

STRONGS NT 5092: τιμή

τιμή, τιμῆς, ἡ (from τίω, to estimate, honor, perfect passive τετιμαι), from Homer down, the Sept. for עֵרֶך (a valuing, rating), כָּבוד, יְקָר, הָדָר;

1. a valuing by which the price is fixed; hence, the price" itself: of the price paid or received for a person or thing bought or sold, with a genitive of the person Matthew 27:9; with a genitive of the thing, Acts 5:2f; plural, Acts 4:34; Acts 19:19; τιμή αἵματος, the price paid for killing, (cf. 'blood-money'), Matthew 27:6; ἠγοράσθητε τιμῆς (not gratis, but) with a piece, i. e. (contextually, with emphasis) at a great price (Buttmann, § 132, 13; yet see Winer's Grammar, 595 (553)), 1 Corinthians 6:20 (here Vulg.magno pretio); ; ὠνεῖσθαι τιμῆς ἀργυρίου, to buy for a price reckoned in silver, i. e. for silver, Acts 7:16; thing prized (A. V. honor), Revelation 21:24 (Rec.), 26.

2. honor which belongs or is shown to one: the honor of one who outranks others, pre-eminence, δόξα καί τιμή, Hebrews 2:7, 9; 2 Peter 1:17; in the doxologies: τῷ Θεῷ (namely, ἔστω (cf. Buttmann, § 129, 22 Rem.)) τιμή or ἡ τιμή, 1 Timothy 1:17; 1 Timothy 6:16; Revelation 5:13; Revelation 7:12; Revelation 19:1 Rec.; the honor which one has by reason of the rank and state of the office which he holds, Hebrews 5:4 (and often in Greek writings; cf. Bleek on Hebrews, the passage cited); veneration: διδόναι, λαβεῖν, τιμήν, Revelation 4:9, 11; Revelation 5:12; deference, reverence, Romans 12:10; Romans 13:7; 1 Timothy 5:17; 1 Timothy 6:1; honor appearing in the rewards of the future life, Romans 2:7, 10; 1 Peter 1:7; praise of which one is judged worthy, 1 Peter 2:7 (here R. V. text preciousness (cf. 1 above)); mark of honor, πολλαῖς τιμαῖς τιμᾶν τινα, Acts 28:10; universally in phrases: ἐν τιμή, honorably, 1 Thessalonians 4:4 (on this passive see κτάομαι); οὐκ ἐν τιμή τίνι, not in any honor, i. e. worthy of no honor, Colossians 2:23 (others, value; see πλησμονή); εἰς τιμήν, Romans 9:21; 2 Timothy 2:20f (on these passages, see σκεῦος, 1); περιτιθεναι τίνι τιμήν, 1 Corinthians 12:23 (see περιτίθημι, b.); τιμήν ἀπονέμειν τίνι, to show honor to one, 1 Peter 3:7; διδόναι τιμήν, 1 Corinthians 12:24; ἔχειν τιμήν, to have honor, be honored, John 4:44; Hebrews 3:3.

Not every word is translated in exact in any translation.
 
mamamia said:
.tim said:
mamamia said:
Sherryh said:
I'm not a missionary............But there is nothing wrong with planning ahead for your family and future. I'm not 20 years old anymore but if I were I would be working 2 jobs and saving for the future. It's really planning ahead which is not wrong.

I have nothing against planning for the future.  But, most missionaries don't work a job outside of their ministry.  I know some missionaries truly struggling to stay on the field, while others are receiving above and beyond what they need allowing them to live in luxury while on the field.  I'm just not sure that's right.

The ones truly struggling ... I often wonder if this is God's way of saying, "time up" .... we never know the total story of a persons life, walk with God, goals .... for all we know, the struggling ones are ignoring a sin God won't let them ignore.

This brings up another topic.  The topic of deputation.  Is deputation Biblical?  My in-laws traveled around the country for a couple of years raising support.  During this time, they were traveling so much that they couldn't keep a job.  They became 100% dependent on churches to keep them on the road in hopes of raising enough support to go on the field.  I remember one occasion that my brother-in-law had been invited to preach at a church in California, the opposite side of the country from us. He drove his family to the west coast, spent 3 days, and only received a love offering of a few hundred dollars which didn't begin to cover the cost of the trip (meals, gas, hotel).  The church eventually took them on for support at $50 a month.  Is it worth it?  And, back to my original question, is deputation Biblical?  Scripture seems pretty clear that we're simply supposed to "go".  It doesn't say that we are to wait around until we have enough money to live comfortably on the field.  It simply says to go.

There are NO biblical examples of modern deputation. NONE. However, it is definitely practical in some circumstances.
 
mamamia said:
.tim said:
mamamia said:
Sherryh said:
I'm not a missionary............But there is nothing wrong with planning ahead for your family and future. I'm not 20 years old anymore but if I were I would be working 2 jobs and saving for the future. It's really planning ahead which is not wrong.

I have nothing against planning for the future.  But, most missionaries don't work a job outside of their ministry.  I know some missionaries truly struggling to stay on the field, while others are receiving above and beyond what they need allowing them to live in luxury while on the field.  I'm just not sure that's right.

The ones truly struggling ... I often wonder if this is God's way of saying, "time up" .... we never know the total story of a persons life, walk with God, goals .... for all we know, the struggling ones are ignoring a sin God won't let them ignore.

This brings up another topic.  The topic of deputation.  Is deputation Biblical?  My in-laws traveled around the country for a couple of years raising support.  During this time, they were traveling so much that they couldn't keep a job.  They became 100% dependent on churches to keep them on the road in hopes of raising enough support to go on the field.  I remember one occasion that my brother-in-law had been invited to preach at a church in California, the opposite side of the country from us. He drove his family to the west coast, spent 3 days, and only received a love offering of a few hundred dollars which didn't begin to cover the cost of the trip (meals, gas, hotel).  The church eventually took them on for support at $50 a month.  Is it worth it?  And, back to my original question, is deputation Biblical?  Scripture seems pretty clear that we're simply supposed to "go".  It doesn't say that we are to wait around until we have enough money to live comfortably on the field.  It simply says to go.

Do they just show up at the airport and see what God does? That seems foolish also. I suppose deputation is the necessary evil one deals with in order to be a missionary - that and dealing with Churches that won't or can't give much.
 
christundivided said:
.tim said:
I did a Google search and found this quote ...

"The discipline of deputation, coupled with a true desire to minister to others, has provided a built-in system of checks and balances to determine the level of perseverance among our missionary force."

http://missionsmandate.org/index.php/2008/12/24/thoughts-on-deputation-from-a-missions-prof-article-2/

Man..... my head almost spun around reading that..... Nice "spin" on the issue.

Unless we have a seasoned missionary among us, we are mostly speaking without a clue.
 
.tim said:
christundivided said:
.tim said:
I did a Google search and found this quote ...

"The discipline of deputation, coupled with a true desire to minister to others, has provided a built-in system of checks and balances to determine the level of perseverance among our missionary force."

http://missionsmandate.org/index.php/2008/12/24/thoughts-on-deputation-from-a-missions-prof-article-2/

Man..... my head almost spun around reading that..... Nice "spin" on the issue.

Unless we have a seasoned missionary among us, we are mostly speaking without a clue.

So.... only a seasoned missionary can make a biblical argument about the issue?
 
christundivided said:
.tim said:
christundivided said:
.tim said:
I did a Google search and found this quote ...

"The discipline of deputation, coupled with a true desire to minister to others, has provided a built-in system of checks and balances to determine the level of perseverance among our missionary force."

http://missionsmandate.org/index.php/2008/12/24/thoughts-on-deputation-from-a-missions-prof-article-2/

Man..... my head almost spun around reading that..... Nice "spin" on the issue.

Unless we have a seasoned missionary among us, we are mostly speaking without a clue.

So.... only a seasoned missionary can make a biblical argument about the issue?

Probably.
 
.tim said:
christundivided said:
.tim said:
christundivided said:
.tim said:
I did a Google search and found this quote ...

"The discipline of deputation, coupled with a true desire to minister to others, has provided a built-in system of checks and balances to determine the level of perseverance among our missionary force."

http://missionsmandate.org/index.php/2008/12/24/thoughts-on-deputation-from-a-missions-prof-article-2/

Man..... my head almost spun around reading that..... Nice "spin" on the issue.

Unless we have a seasoned missionary among us, we are mostly speaking without a clue.

So.... only a seasoned missionary can make a biblical argument about the issue?

Probably.

You sure are gullible.
 
mamamia said:
.tim said:
mamamia said:
.tim said:
mamamia said:
Sherryh said:
I'm not a missionary............But there is nothing wrong with planning ahead for your family and future. I'm not 20 years old anymore but if I were I would be working 2 jobs and saving for the future. It's really planning ahead which is not wrong.

I have nothing against planning for the future.  But, most missionaries don't work a job outside of their ministry.  I know some missionaries truly struggling to stay on the field, while others are receiving above and beyond what they need allowing them to live in luxury while on the field.  I'm just not sure that's right.

The ones truly struggling ... I often wonder if this is God's way of saying, "time up" .... we never know the total story of a persons life, walk with God, goals .... for all we know, the struggling ones are ignoring a sin God won't let them ignore.

This brings up another topic.  The topic of deputation.  Is deputation Biblical?  My in-laws traveled around the country for a couple of years raising support.  During this time, they were traveling so much that they couldn't keep a job.  They became 100% dependent on churches to keep them on the road in hopes of raising enough support to go on the field.  I remember one occasion that my brother-in-law had been invited to preach at a church in California, the opposite side of the country from us. He drove his family to the west coast, spent 3 days, and only received a love offering of a few hundred dollars which didn't begin to cover the cost of the trip (meals, gas, hotel).  The church eventually took them on for support at $50 a month.  Is it worth it?  And, back to my original question, is deputation Biblical?  Scripture seems pretty clear that we're simply supposed to "go".  It doesn't say that we are to wait around until we have enough money to live comfortably on the field.  It simply says to go.

Do they just show up at the airport and see what God does? That seems foolish also. I suppose deputation is the necessary evil one deals with in order to be a missionary - that and dealing with Churches that won't or can't give much.

No...I think a sending church should support a missionary 100%.  Maybe treat it like a church plant.  If a church can't support a missionary 100%, then perhaps that missionary should help grow the church first.  Just a thought.

It makes you wonder if any Churches currently follow this model ....
 
christundivided said:
.tim said:
christundivided said:
.tim said:
christundivided said:
.tim said:
I did a Google search and found this quote ...

"The discipline of deputation, coupled with a true desire to minister to others, has provided a built-in system of checks and balances to determine the level of perseverance among our missionary force."

http://missionsmandate.org/index.php/2008/12/24/thoughts-on-deputation-from-a-missions-prof-article-2/

Man..... my head almost spun around reading that..... Nice "spin" on the issue.

Unless we have a seasoned missionary among us, we are mostly speaking without a clue.

So.... only a seasoned missionary can make a biblical argument about the issue?

Probably.

You sure are gullible.

Probably. But, I just know that a man who has driven 30,000 miles to get support, 25+ years on the field, and countless hours dealing with issues on the field would probably have wiser contributions & perspectives on the issue. That all.
 
Back
Top