- Joined
- Jan 30, 2013
- Messages
- 4,083
- Reaction score
- 2,325
- Points
- 113
i just saw this for the first time today... ... from the looks of it it;s going to be a movie
about all the things to never do as a diver... . ..... the people who commented say the
book makes things much clearer and in fact makes it clear the main character is not an
experienced diver.... ... so obviously either the dad (josh brolin).... doesn;t have time
to teach him much before he disappears... or else did not really know much himself ....
not sure about the concept of a sperm whale swallowing a diver complete with his scuba gear
either..... or a human being able to survive the acids in a whales stomach once swallowed...
..(maybe it;s a specially prepared whale like the one that swallowed jonah....)..
but thankfully the movie comes out in october.... so i;ll have plenty of time to read the book
before seeing the movie... ..i don;t know if my dad has seen this yet or not... .can;t wait to
find out what he thinks about it....... .

about all the things to never do as a diver... . ..... the people who commented say the
book makes things much clearer and in fact makes it clear the main character is not an
experienced diver.... ... so obviously either the dad (josh brolin).... doesn;t have time
to teach him much before he disappears... or else did not really know much himself ....
not sure about the concept of a sperm whale swallowing a diver complete with his scuba gear
either..... or a human being able to survive the acids in a whales stomach once swallowed...
..(maybe it;s a specially prepared whale like the one that swallowed jonah....)..
but thankfully the movie comes out in october.... so i;ll have plenty of time to read the book
before seeing the movie... ..i don;t know if my dad has seen this yet or not... .can;t wait to
find out what he thinks about it....... .

Last edited:
