Trump is now a political liability.

I’m asking you if you believed the war was unjustified?
You’re not listening to me. Asking if a single war is justified or unjustified is an extremely complicated and nuanced, ethical, and subjectively argumentative process. It’s much simpler to understand that human life begins at conception. Based upon that simple premise, it’s much easier to argue politically for which one holds a higher priority for my voting as a Christian.

And here’s some more reading on just war, specifically regarding Vietnam. If you care to take the time to expand your thinking, this will sustain exactly what I’m trying to tell you, and I bet you probably, at least on some rudimentary level, already understand what it’s saying.
 
It is a fallacy that any war can be fought without collateral damage. My father fought in the Battle of Iwo Jima in World War 2 which was the bloodiest battle of the war with 7,000 Americans killed and 20,000 wounded. He came back with shell shock and when I was still a child he would wake up in the middle of the night with nightmares. It wasn’t uncommon for bears to roam into populated areas where we lived and one night when my aunt and uncle were visiting from South Carolina, my dad woke up in the middle the night screaming. My uncle cautiously crept to his bedroom and said, “Ervin!, Ervin!, there aren’t any bears in there are there?” My Dad rarely talked about Iwo Jima and never attended any reunions of that battle but he did tell me that after he left Iwo Jima on a ship headed for mainland Japan, he knew that he was going to die and the only thing that saved him and a million other Americans along with countless Japanese civilians, was that President Truman dropped the Bomb. I have read reports that Japanese women and children had sticks in their hands willing to fight to the death for their country. Emperor Hirohito was considered a god and their religious fanaticism had them in the mindset of suicide for their cause.

There is no difference between the religious fanaticism of Muslim clerics in Iran who have vowed to destroy America and can only do that with nuclear weapons attached to ICBM’s. At one point they told President Trump they were about a week away from getting those weapons. I believe he is justified in preventing that.
Iwo Jima, was justified.

Thanks for sharing the story about your dad.

I have a very very close friend that fought in Iraq and he’s never been the same. He was working a check point. They were ordered to shoot the vehicles if they did not stop. Well, one day the vehicle didn’t stop. They did shoot the vehicle and killed children in the vehicle.

Iwo Jima, justified war. Your father came back and had to deal with things in his head we couldn’t imagine.

Now add to that a war like Iraq, unjustified. Dealing with things like your father, killing kids and now dealing with a war that we should’ve never been involved with. Telling yourself, all this for what?
 
I am not for murder, in the womb, or out. It’s much easier to make the case abortion is murder than your claim about unjust military action(s).
"No Standing Army"...Only an invasion of the homeland is justification for War in Our Constitutional Republic.
Other than that, We are supposed to be about our family and business.
 
Iwo Jima, was justified.
Who ultimately decides whether a war is actually justified or not? You? Are you the final arbiter of just vs unjust wars? Depending upon your culture, religion, generation, race/ethnicity, location, etc., the definition of a justified war is very easily fluid. I think that’s @ALAYMAN point.
 
You’re not listening to me. Asking if a single war is justified or unjustified is an extremely complicated and nuanced, ethical, and subjectively argumentative process. It’s much simpler to understand that human life begins at conception. Based upon that simple premise, it’s much easier to argue politically for which one holds a higher priority for my voting as a Christian.

And here’s some more reading on just war, specifically regarding Vietnam. If you care to take the time to expand your thinking, this will sustain exactly what I’m trying to tell you, and I bet you probably, at least on some rudimentary level, already understand what it’s saying.
My understanding of this article is, we should learn from Iraq, Vietnam and Afghanistan but do not allow the failures of those wars to convince you that all military involvement is wrong.

Correct?
 
Who ultimately decides whether a war is actually justified or not? You? Are you the final arbiter of just vs unjust wars? Depending upon your culture, religion, generation, race/ethnicity, location, etc., the definition of a justified war is very easily fluid. I think that’s @ALAYMAN point.
I feel like History decides. However, I’m learning that there are people who actually believe that Iraq was justified (mind blown) the first time I heard that was from a relative, recently.

Maybe most things are fluid?

But don’t get it twisted, I believe Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Iran, Lybia and others were needless wars. That’s my view and understand 20 plus years later.

If people wanna believe it’s fluid that’s fine. We do live in America and I’ve learned it’s not their kids dying and or coming back to deal with what happened over there in their head. It’s typically the parents that have no children on the front lines that believe it’s fluid. Their kids are in college somewhere learning to debate in favor of wars.
 
Last edited:
At one point they told President Trump they were about a week away from getting those weapons.
Can you document this statement? Who are "they" who told Trump that "they" (presumably Iran) were "about a week away from getting nuclear weapons attached to ICBM's?" Did "Muslim clerics in Iran" tell Trump this? The closest thing I can find is that Steve Witcoff, who is not an Iranian Muslim cleric, stated that “They are probably a week away from having industrial grade bomb making material." This statement was contested by various experts.

 
Can you document this statement? Who are "they" who told Trump that "they" (presumably Iran) were "about a week away from getting nuclear weapons attached to ICBM's?" Did "Muslim clerics in Iran" tell Trump this? The closest thing I can find is that Steve Witcoff, who is not an Iranian Muslim cleric, stated that “They are probably a week away from having industrial grade bomb making material." This statement was contested by various experts.

This report says it was the Iranian negotiators that made the claim they could make 11 nuclear bombs and I read another report that they claimed it was within a week. I don’t know if it is true any more than you do. But why would we not take Iran at their word with such threats.

 
You talk about Benjamin Netanyahu. Why not take Iran's words when they say they are going to destroy us and are developing nuclear weapons to achieve that purpose? You don't have any top secret information on the subject any more than I do.
Iran is at war with us and Israel™. Liars abound all around.
 
Biscuit, the article you posted in #369 provides no evidence about Iran being "about a week away from getting nuclear weapons attached to ICBMs." I'll take that as an admission on your part that you have no evidence that this was going to happen. Actually, you have already admitted it.

I don’t know if it is true any more than you do.

I don't see how it helps the discussion about the war in Iran, for anyone to come on this forum and make dramatic statements for which no one can provide evidence, and where even those who posted the statements admit that they don't know if it is true or not.

For those who didn't read Biscuit's article, here is a quote from it.

"Last May, the Defense Intelligence Agency said in its worldwide threat assessment that Iran had taken actions to reduce the amount of time needed to produce enough weapons-grade uranium for a first nuclear device, but the report cast doubt that the country was making bombs. 'Iran almost certainly is not producing nuclear weapons.'. . ."
 
Were the wars God led His people into in the OT justified?

Was He justified in destroying the Egyptian army at the Red Sea?
 
Were the wars God led His people into in the OT justified?

Was He justified in destroying the Egyptian army at the Red Sea?
Isreal™ are not His people. They are the synagogue of Satan. But you see, there is no justification for Israel™ apart from a form of Darbyism.

It always boils down to that.

Always.
 
Back
Top