Jewish Citizens Targeted: 12 Dead

In Judaism, this individual is considered a Jew, even if he is an atheist. There are practicing Jews, and non-practicing Jews, but their identity has nothing to do with genealogy, and everything to do with their relationship to the Torah.
Do you realize that you just contradicted yourself in your own statement? This isn’t rocket science.
 
No I didn't. Substitute the word Christian for Jew, and you'll get the gist.
Would it make a difference to you if there was a concerted effort at Bondi Beach to kill Buddhists? Hindus? Zoroastrians?

The point is, I don’t think most people here get your fascination with excusing the murder and persecution of people, regardless of whether they identify with any specific ethnic/religious identity.
 
Would it make a difference to you if there was a concerted effort at Bondi Beach to kill Buddhists? Hindus? Zoroastrians?

The point is, I don’t think most people here get your fascination with excusing the murder and persecution of people, regardless of whether they identify with any specific ethnic/religious identity.
There certainly wouldn't be the attention to it if they were Buddhists, Hindus, or Zoroastrians. I'm not justifying anything, but one thing is certain, given the crimes of Israel™, and its recent esacalation in its pursuit of Greater Israel™, there's no wonder that attacks on Jews all over the world are spiking.

Tarhead is wrong to assert that it's just an irrational hatred of a race (that doesn't really exist any more). More than that, he knows it. He might say he thinks Judaism is a false religion, but in practice, he thinks there's still some validity to it, otherwise there could be no support for the Zionist state that has usurped the name of Israel.

My entrance into this thread has nothing to do with the event, however. abcaines thought he was being clever, and that's my springboard into this discussion.
 
There certainly wouldn't be the attention to it if they were Buddhists, Hindus, or Zoroastrians.

But I didn’t ask about whether there was a disproportionate amount of attention given to crimes against Jews versus other religions. I simply stated that you have what appears to be an irrational fascination with justifying what you’ve describe as retaliation towards them.
 
So "an Israelite or a descendant of them," then?
LOL, "Israelite." A descendant, but not necessarily of Jacob. You readily accept the fact that the 10 northern tribes in just a few hundred years were lost. What do you think 2000 years would do to Judah and Benjamin?

What is a distinquishing characteristic of the Hebrew race? Netanyahu is a pasty white European. The only thing that makes one a Jew, whether he be Ethiopian, Greek, or a pasty white European is Judaism. And Judaism is defined by the Talmud, not the Bible, or Zionism.
 
Last edited:
But I didn’t ask about whether there was a disproportionate amount of attention given to crimes against Jews versus other religions. I simply stated that you have what appears to be an irrational fascination with justifying what you’ve describe as retaliation towards them.
Only to those with Jewish idols in their hearts, it seems.
 
No I didn't. Substitute the word Christian for Jew, and you'll get the gist.
In your eyes, is a non-religious person with the last name “Goldstein” or “Cohen” not entitled to call themselves “Jewish”?
 
You readily accept the fact that the 10 northern tribes in just a few hundred years were lost.

News to me, if I do. Why don't you go join biscuit at the kids' table? He's probably lonely, wondering why he's the only one who ever gets called out for foolish assumptions.
 
News to me, if I do. Why don't you go join biscuit at the kids' table? He's probably lonely, wondering why he's the only one who ever gets called out for foolish assumptions.
Oh. Well pardon me for not realizing you had some secret knowledge or insight into things the Jews themselves say was lost.

Can I assume you believe in the law of gravity?
 
Back
Top