"We need to intentionally differentiate between God-given talents and spiritual gifts. The ability to think deeply (Ravi Zacharias; Steven Lawson), communicate effectively (Tony Evans; Joshua Harris), administrate efficiently (Bill Hybels; Jerry Falwell, Jr.), or write well (Philip Yancey; Jerry Jenkins) does not prove that a person is right with God. In fact, talents too often camouflage sins."
Kenny Baldwin: sexual misconduct.
Ravi Zacharias: sexual misconduct.
Steven Lawson: sexual misconduct.
Bill Hybels: sexual misconduct.
Jerry Falwell, Jr.: sexual misconduct.
Philip Yancey: sexual misconduct.
Joshua Harris: apostasy.
Jerry B. Jenkins: played poker.
While I strongly disapprove of gambling and recognize that it generally falls outside of evangelical approval, I think we can agree that entering a poker tournament isn't even in the same ballpark, morally speaking, as having an affair or sending explicit pictures to teenagers.
Tony Evans, too: he stepped down due to a confessed, though undisclosed, moral failure, which his church handled internally and apparently did not view as permanently disqualifying. Without knowing the details, that should settle the matter.
Remember that Jack Schaap once infamously screeched from the pulpit about teenage girls using their phones to sext boys--and then his own illicit affair with a teenager was revealed when someone inadvertently saw a text message from her on his phone. Shiflett's response smacks of "I thank thee that I am not like other men," more than a proper attitude of humility where his own sinful nature is concerned.